Before I ever held a real estate license, I held a hammer. I built homes on the Southside from 1974 to 1992, and I can tell you that walking a construction site changes how you look at a house forever. So when buyers ask me the question I’m hearing more than any other this summer, “Should we build new or buy resale?”, I answer it differently than most agents can.And right now, on the Southside, it’s a question worth asking. Drive through Franklin Township, down through Greenwood, or out toward Bargersville and you’ll see framing crews everywhere. New construction is a bigger part of our local inventory than it has been in years, and the builders want your business badly enough to pay for it.
The incentives are real but so is the fine print
Here’s what’s true: national builders have something individual home sellers don’t, margin to play with. Many are offering interest rate buydowns that can put your mortgage rate well below what the open market is charging, along with closing cost credits and free upgrades. For the right buyer, that’s real money. I’ve seen buydowns worth more than most sellers could ever negotiate off a resale price.Here’s what’s also true: those incentives usually come with strings. They’re typically tied to using the builder’s preferred lender. The advertised base price rarely includes the lot premium, the upgraded flooring, or the kitchen you actually saw in the model. And things you take for granted in a resale home, blinds, a finished yard, a fence, sometimes even a refrigerator, often aren’t included at all. The model home is the builder’s best salesperson. Your job is to know what the house you’re actually buying will look like.
Two pieces of advice from my builder years
First: bring your own representation. The friendly agent in the model home works for the builder, that’s their job, and most do it honestly, but they are not negotiating for you. Having your own agent costs you nothing and gives you someone reading the contract, the allowances, and the timeline with your interests in mind.Second: get an inspection on new construction. I mean it. People assume a brand-new home doesn’t need one. As someone who built homes for 18 years, I’ll tell you the opposite: every house is built by human beings, dozens of them, working fast. Good builders welcome an independent set of eyes. The ones who resist it are telling you something.
Don’t count resale out
Meanwhile, the resale homes in our established Southside neighborhoods offer things no builder can deliver in 2026: mature trees, larger lots, settled drainage, known property taxes, and all those finished extras already in place. When you add up what it costs to take a new build from “closing day” to “actually done”, yard, fence, blinds, patio, the price gap between new and resale often shrinks more than people expect.
And if you’re selling? You’re competing with the builders
One more thing, because it matters to a lot of you reading this: if you’re selling a home in the $300,000–$500,000 range right now, the builder down the road offering a rate buydown is your competition. That doesn’t mean you can’t win; well-maintained, move-in-ready, correctly priced homes are still selling well here. But it does mean condition and pricing strategy matter more than they have in years. That’s a conversation worth having before your sign goes in the yard.Here’s my mother’s test on this one: if my own mother asked me whether to build or buy resale, I wouldn’t give her a slogan. I’d sit down with her actual numbers and timeline and walk both paths honestly. That’s exactly what we’ll do with you. Call us at 317-882-7210, after 50 years on both sides of this question, we can help you ask the right ones.
See other articles like this on our Team Blog.